Towards Harmonized Hate Crime Laws: Bridging Legal Gaps for Human Dignity and Inclusion in the EU and International Systems

Abstract

This paper analyzes the inconsistent legal responses within the EU and international systems to hate crimes against Muslims, especially incidents involving desecration or insults toward the Holy Quran. It highlights the growing tension between freedom of religion, freedom of expression, and protections against hate speech—three rights often treated separately rather than in an interconnected manner. Due to the absence of harmonized legal standards, significant protection gaps persist, disproportionately affecting Muslim communities. By comparing national laws, EU instruments, ECtHR case law, and UN standards, the paper identifies approaches for better balancing these rights. It ultimately calls for clearer and more coherent legal frameworks that safeguard both the dignity of religious minorities and fundamental freedoms.