Is the Interpretation of the Tenor in “Tombe degli avi miei” from “Lucia di Lammermoor” by G. Donizetti, Lyric or Dramatic?

Abstract

This study is an analysis of the tenor interpretation of the aria Tombe degli avi miei from Lucia di Lammermoor by G. Donizetti. It studies 4 different recordings of tenors with 30 years approximately between them. It analyses the interpretation perspective of them. Should it be more dramatic or lyric? there have been both tenors performing this role with acclaimed reviews. The dramatic tenor has an easiness on showing the drama and the passion aspect of the aria. The lyric tenor has a refined phrasing and beauty of line that fits well the character and the belcanto style.